| 1971: Bob Downs – Northern Illinois University |
1998: Joe Curry – Indiana State/Univ. of St. Francis* |
| 1971: Rick Jakious – University of Wisconsin |
1998: Joe Hopp Jr. – Monmouth College |
| 1971: John Weber – Illinois Benedictine College |
1998: Brad Hulke – Monmouth College |
| 1971: Bob Padilla – University of Dubuque |
1998: Tim Wolf – Carroll College |
| 1975: Tim Barkei – Eureka College |
1998: Larry Gainey – Loras College |
| 1977: Brett DeKing – North Central College |
1999: Jeremiah Shupe – Rockford College |
| 1979: Dan Edmeier – Loras College* |
1999: Kevin Hopp – Loras College |
| 1979: Paul Edmeier – Loras College* |
2000: Rory Quinn – St. Ambrose University |
| 1980: Paul Perez – University of Oregon |
2002: Todd Murphy – Aurora University |
| 1983: Leroy DeKing – North Central College |
2003: Chuck Gainey – Loras College |
| 1983: Paul Piscoran – West Point Academy |
2003: Craig Hurd – St. Ambrose University |
| 1984: Dave Wagner – North Central College |
2003: Adam Bohr – Illinois Wesleyan University |
| 1985: Mike Holzer – North Central College |
2004: Matt Benjamin – St. Ambrose University |
| 1985: John Stull – Western Illinois University |
2004: Colin Dart – St. John University |
| 1986: Kevin McCabe – Augustana College |
2004: Aaron Rozanski – Iowa Wesleyan University |
| 1986: Morrell Pruitte – North Central College |
2005: Mike Benjamin – University of St. Francis |
| 1986: Jeff Watkins – Augustana College |
2005: Luke Brauweiler – Beloit College |
| 1987: Jack Gieck – Aurora University |
2006: Jim Gaddis – Aurora University |
| 1987: Scott Scharrer – Aurora University |
2006: Jesus Gonzalez – Aurora University |
| 1988: Chad Braun – Illinois College |
2007: Chad Roscoe – University of Wisconin – Platteville |
| 1988: Mike Davis – St. Ambrose University |
2007: Billy Balderas – College of DuPage |
| 1988: Chris Kulbartz – Joliet Junior College |
2007: Kyle Edwards – North Park University |
| 1988: Dave Moisa – St. Ambrose University |
2008: Mike Adams – No. Cen. College/Aurora University |
| 1989: Joe Garcia – Aurora University |
2008: Tom Barkei – Iowa Wesleyan University |
| 1989: Jamie Rivera – Illinois Valley College |
2009: Robert Reier – University of Wisconsin – Platteville |
| 1989: Corey Thompson – North Central College |
2009: Alex Schaefer – UW-Platteville/Aurora University |
| 1989: Aldwin Turnage – UNLV |
2010: John Belovich – Loras College |
| 1991: George Monaco – Aurora University |
2010: Adam Blake – Aurora University |
| 1991: Doug Regnier – Augustana College |
2010: Kent Brauweiler – Iowa Wesleyan University |
| 1992: Ryan Lohrey – Illinois Benedictine College |
2010: Nick Mytnik – Joliet Junior College |
| 1992: Aaron Saling – St. Ambrose University |
|
| 1994: Chris Rozanski – North Central College |
|
| 1995: Steve Cruz – St. Ambrose University |
|
| 1995: Nate Kinkel – St. Ambrose University |
|
| 1995: Pat Langan – St. Ambrose University |
|
| 1995: Chad Peterson – North Park College |
|
| 1995: Bryan Rozanski – Illinois Benedictine College |
|
| 1995: Quincy Turnage – Aurora University |
|
| 1997: Jim Beamon – North Central College |
|
| 1997: Larry Miller – Loras College |
|
| 1997: Tim Peterson – MacMurray* |
|
| 1997: Marchel Rogers – Southern Illinois University |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| * All-American |
